Clefs for Music Notation

A clef is a musical symbol placed at the beginning of a staff to indicate the pitch of the notes on the staff. “Clef” is the French word for “key”. Clefs first started appearing in music scores in the late 1500’s as letters placed precisely on a specific staff line to identify letter-named pitches, which provided a “key” to their identity.

In modern music, there are three main clef designs / shapes we use for pitched music, plus some ancillary clefs used for percussion instruments, tablature and so forth.

0201-main-clefs-in-use-today

Clefs have proven to be an effective way of dealing with the extreme ranges represented by all of the instruments in use today. The modern pitched staff is only five lines, so using different clefs assigned to different registers allows us to present each staff in a much more readable way for each specific instrument’s tessitura.

The pitched clefs in common use today are the treble clef, the bass clef and the C-clef. The treble clef is also known as the G-clef; the curl of the treble clef highlights a reference line for the note G above middle C (the current clef shape has evolved from the letter G). The bass clef is also known as the F-clef, because the note F below middle C passes between the two dots of the bass clef shape (this clef was originally the letter F).

The clefs assign a specific reference note to the line on which they are placed. The other lines and spaces are read in relation to this reference line.

The alto clef and the tenor clef are actually the same clef design, set at different locations on the staff to represent the location for middle C; this clef is referred to as the C-clef or the movable C-clef. For alto clef, the C-clef sits on the third line of the staff, indicating the location of middle C. For tenor clef, the C-clef sites on the fourth line of the staff, indicating middle C (for a total of four standard pitched clefs in common use).

Historically, the movable C-clef could appear on any of the five staff lines indicating the position of middle C; however, the alto and tenor clefs are the only movable C-clefs in common use today.


OCTAVE CLEFS


If you’ve read or written music for choir, you’re probably familiar with a variation of the treble clef with a small 8 positioned below it used for tenor voice. This clef is frequently referred to as the tenor vocal clef. Music for tenor is written in the treble clef, but sounds an octave lower than written.

You may have also seen other octave versions of both the treble and bass clef.

0204-octave-clefs

The location of the small 8 above or below a treble or bass clef indicates the direction of the sounding octave. For instance, a clef with a small 8 positioned below it indicates that the part will sound 8vb from where written; an 8 positioned above the clef indicates the part will sound 8va. Two octaves up or down is indicated with a small number 15 above or below the clef. Sometimes, this octave displacement reminder is shown parenthesized.

It’s worth noting that this is an older convention. While you still occasionally see various octave clefs in scores, the tenor vocal clef is the only one of these octave clefs still in widespread use.

In modern scores, octave-displaced instruments such as the glockenspiel, piccolo, guitar, contrabassoon or contrabass are most often written using the normal treble or bass clef without the small 8 or 15 above or below the clef. It is understood that these instruments actually sound an octave or two from where written; the small 8 (or 15) above or below the clef is essentially just a reminder which has fallen out of popular use.


VIVE LA DIFFÉRENCE!


Finale and Sibelius handle octave clefs a bit differently.

In Sibelius, the visual clef itself is not actually tied to playback; instead, everything related to transposition  (including octave displacement) is part of the instrument definition. So, for instance, if you change the clef from treble to tenor vocal clef in an existing staff, neither the visual pitch, or the playback octave will change. However, if you change the *Instrument definition* from Soprano to Tenor voice, not only will the clef change; the written pitch will be raised an octave as well, to correspond to the current sounding pitch.

In Finale, if you you change the clef from treble to the tenor vocal clef, the written pitch will immediately be raised an octave to correspond to the current *sounding* pitch regardless of the instrument assignment. You can also create a new instrument or assign an instrument change to a staff, which may include an octave-displaced clef (which affects playback) as part of its overall definition.


DIALOGUE


Both Finale and Sibelius offer a number of clef choices. 

Here is the Finale Clef Dialog:

0202-finale-clef-dialog

… and here is the Sibelius 7 Clef Gallery:

0203-sib-clef-dialog

That’s it for now – Happy Holidays!
~robert

RELATED ARTICLES

5 Replies to “Clefs for Music Notation”

  1. What happens when a clef changes in the middle of a piece of music? For example from treble to Bass, and then back to treble. I play the horn by the way.

    1. Great question, Ryan. Finale and Sibelius handle clef changes a bit differently. Whether during entry, or making a clef change after the music has been entered, say from Treble to Bass (or the reverse of that), the two programs work the same. If you change from treble to bass clef in either program, the note positions relative to the staff will be changed to correspond to the bass clef version of that same pitch. So for example, middle C the line below the treble clef staff becomes middle C the line above the bass clef staff.

      Where it gets interesting is with octave displacing clefs (e.g. such as a tenor vocal clef with the 8 below the clef tail). Finale actually interprets these by moving the clef to the octave indicated by the “8”, but to Sibelius *any* type of clef with the same shape and location relative to the staff is always that clef, even with the octave displacement. In the case of Sibelius, the pitches do not move on the staff at all. If you change a treble clef to a tenor vocal clef (treble clef with the 8 below it) the pitches relative to the staff are not changed as they are in Finale.

      I hope that is helpful info.

  2. re: <>

    FYI, MuseScore behaves like Finale with regard to changing from the treble clef to the tenor vocal clef. Visually, the notes jump up an octave, but they sound the same as before the change.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.