Finale’s audio output has the potential to generate great audio and wonderful-sounding scores for consumers and demos. For the majority of users, the default settings are adequate. Midi/Audio>Play Finale Through Audio Units should be selected in order to activate Garritan Instruments for Finale (or Garritan’s premium libraries. For more information on setup for these libraries, see this article on the Scoring Notes blog: “Getting Started in Finale with Garritan’s Premium Libraries”). For those working on larger scores in pursuit of the best possible quality, however, the defaults might not work well. Let’s take a look at how to address common problems you may encounter, and create the best possible mix in Finale.
Mix issues with Finale default settings
First stop – Mixer Window
Start by opening Window>Mixer, and get basic levels with the faders. Sometimes, that just won’t do it.
Some instruments are out of balance, even with the same dynamic marking in score
When you find yourself adding unusual dynamic markings (“pppp” when everybody else is “mf”) in an attempt to balance the instruments in a score, it’s time to revisit your “starting” balance. Some default instruments are way too quiet – drum kits in particular – and some are too loud, particularly some plucked strings (such as Ukelele and Mandolin), and solo (vs “section”) woodwind player samples.
A good solution for drums is to assign your desired dynamic in the score, so it shows up in the part correctly – but then, override it for Finale playback with the Midi Tool. Finale drums have a really wide dynamic range depending on Velocity. The default velocity for score note entries is 64, which would be mp (no wonder it’s inaudible). I’m finding that a velocity of at least 100 (which would be ff in the score) sounds like a “normal” playback level.
Another solution would be to create another set of Dynamics expressions for use in drums only, and boost the values by 35 for each one.
Do it with Banks
Another solution would be to move Instruments to a new bank, with “too loud” instruments assigned to a new bank, and “too quiet” instruments to another, then adjust the bank’s volume using Midi/Audio>Audio Units Banks and Effects> Bank Volume slider.
It’s better to leave some acoustic “headroom” for your initial levels – make everything a bit quieter than you like, leaving room for crescendi and ffff’s.
(headroom is the space between your track’s maximum level and the maximum possible, or “0db’)
► I’ve found that the internal mix in Finale drum kits tend to be heavy on the bass drum and light on the cymbals. It’s possible to change the balance within the drum kit in Midi/Audio>Audio Units Banks and Effects>Bank>Edit Aria Player>Select Drum Slot>Instrument Controls
Set the Playback Buffer to the maximum value
The default playback buffer in Audio settings may not be high enough. Begin by changing the playback buffer in Midi/Audio>Audio Units Banks and Effects>Device Setup>Audio Setup>
“Internal clipping” (cumulative audio too loud) causes dropouts in playback.
When your mix runs out of headroom, it hits the maximum, causing “clipping,” meaning the “overs” cause distortion or overload.
Having more instruments in your score creates a higher cumulative audio level. When it gets over a certain point, Finale’s audio drops out. When these occur, it’s necessary to reduce audio levels within the Finale application before they reach the master output.
Instrument levels can be set in 5 different places in Finale:
A) The Mixer Window (Window>Mixer) should be the first stop in trying to get a balance at expected dynamic levels
B) Dynamic Marks in the score
Define these as you’d like the (potential) players to see them, as interpretive direction for human beings. Although they can be used for mix purposes, make sure you set your basic mix levels first.. It’s good to make liberal use of dynamics in the score, as well as other markings, which are translated by Finale’s Human Playback into control parameters. Slurs, accents and other articulations, and hairpins all convert to Continuous Controller data, affecting playback sound characteristics. New (or reiterated) dynamic marks are essential to reset levels after events such as hairpins (crescendo and decrescendo).
C) Midi/Audio>Audio Units Banks and Effects> Bank and Master volume sliders
As suggested above, Bank and Master levels work on groups of instruments or the mix as a whole, helping to set your basic mix level. Reducing these levels might work as a quick way to eliminate clipping.
Although it’s possible to add plugins to Banks and the Master output in this dialog, offering quick & dirty mastering, I’ve found inserting plugins tends to increase playback errors when exporting audio. With all the headroom you’ll have in your file to get clean audio, mastering with another app will produce the best results. The free audio app Audacity has plugin processing capability, as do many other apps such as the digital audio workstations Logic, Pro Tools, and Cubase Adobe Audition, DSP Quattro, and others. More often than not, all your file will need is normalization.
Finale has control over reverb, and each bank has master reverb controls accessible via the Aria Player. Both of these options are more reliable than third-party plugins for these effects.
Note: although there’s a master reverb showing in Window>Mixer, it doesn’t work with VST playback, including Garritan instruments. Garritan Ambience is added via Midi/Audio>Audio Units Banks and Effects>Edit Bank>Effects, at the Bank level. Adding effects otherwise is likely to cause playback and audio export issues, unless you have a lot of RAM and a really fast processor.
For further control of sound in a mix, it’s possible to export your midi to your DAW, load up the Aria Player, assign the tracks, bounce the audio into new tracks in your DAW, then start mixing (see this article on the Finale Blog for more info).
Although you can get high-quality, professional results within Finale, the DAW option may work better for you if you’re using a lot of third party libraries, scoring to film, and other more demanding applications. It’s possible to run Finale as a stereo VST instrument from within your DAW, and host other players, samplers, and effects there.
D) Score Manager
Use the Score Manager to make numerical, accurate adjustments to the instruments in your score quickly. While Studio View and the Mixer offer faders for interactive adjustment of relative levels, if you’ve got a big score it’s a good idea to reduce the volume of all instruments during setup.
In order to be able to make these adjustments in the Score Manager, be sure Score Manager>Customize View>Mix is checked to display the column holding the values.
Finale’s default sets all levels to 101. For an orchestral score, I set them all to 60 to ensure adequate headroom. It’s possible to navigate this dialog with the keyboard (with the arrow/selection tool active in the Tool palette).
Running a macro script in an app such as Keyboard Maestro makes this task much faster and easier. This screenshot shows steps for an example script to quickly set volume levels. The script types the numeric value, confirms the entry, then navigates down to the next instrument – repeat the trigger to change all default volume levels down the score quickly.
E) Studio View faders
Found in View>Studio View, these mimic a DAW on an elementary level. Studio view offers control of imported audio files and the means to create a tempo map for your track. The moves in the faders are not saved – only the last used setting – and they’re very difficult to use to reset all levels, as in C) above. There is no numeric or arrow key editing.
Strings sound “blocky” or disjointed
Each instrument has adjustable parameters found in the Aria Player. Default string sounds can benefit from increasing the Portamento setting, while having phrase marks (“slurs”) in the score helps smooth out playback in the score. If the score is finished in a DAW, audio tracks can be bounced into the session, then duplicated, with entrances and cutoffs overlapped to further approximate a live orchestra.
In GPO, it’s possible to trigger string samples later in the sample, after the long swell attack, by creating an Expression sending CC#68 a value of 127, to get them on the beat.
Even if the mix is going to be finished in a DAW, getting a good mix in Finale will save a lot of time after import. When bouncing out tracks from Finale’s midi within a DAW, playing back through instances of the Aria Player, your mix will already be in reasonable shape, ready for fine-tuning and enhancement with overlaps and effects.
Author Jon Burr is the proprietor of Arranger for Hire, a veteran arranger, composer and bassist, and a contributor to Scoring Notes, the Finale Blog and OF NOTE.
10 Replies to “Getting a Good Mix in Finale”
Wonderful ingormatipn. Thank you.
I am using EW and EWQL libraries. Until the recent EW PLAY update EW Symphonic Choirs worked very well, including WordBuilder. Now everything written for choir is played back as if the sustain pedal of a piano was being held throughout the piece. The resulting cacophany is terrible. Do you have any suggestions?
Thank you for the Mr. Rogers link. I was very happy when my kids were watching his show.
Jon Burr, thanks! And thanks OF NOTE for sharing your great posts every week!
Jon Burr, thank you so much for your post. Thanks again.
Based on this, I thought I would try exporting midi from Finale and using a DAW to assign instruments there. What a gas! Usually I tweak the FInale file to the edge of its capability, output AIFFs, and make final details in a DAW – that is, I am primarily mixing tracks as a recording studio (I can adjust for inconsistent line levels, and adding a few extra details make the results spectacular). I am looking forward to further experimentation with the midi – and I could make a template if only the tracks came in the same order as my score.
I hate to be snitty … but, and I must say “but”, I wanted to ask if there is some type of aversion in many blogs to ignore PC users of Finale? :)
Well, Enrique – if I was using both a Mac and a PC, maybe I could write a dual-platform post… but I don’t. What I wonder is, since I have a mac (have since 1993), why would I want to use a PC?…
Thanks for responding, Jon. No practical reason except reaching a larger audience with your insights. I had Macs in the 80s but after working for a PC firm in the 90s, I learned to build my own machines and tailor and update each version as I saw fit. :)
Thank you for a clear & straightforward guide to setting levels. It surprised me how hard it was to find the relevant info – certainly not available from Make Music!
Given that the Mix window effects controls don’t work for VST/AU, I misunderstood that the level controls wouldn’t work when I wrote the article. It turns out that the Mix Window is a good first stop to set levels, having the same effect as setting the numbers in the Score Manager. With both open, you can see the faders changing the numbers in the score manager. The panning also works..
….But…you still might need to change bank assignments for some instruments… drums particularly. Can’t seem to get them loud enough with the Mix window..